Southern Kitchen Bucket List : Pie Crust.

As part of my Southern Kitchen Bucket List, I figured there was no better time than now to try to master Pie Crust. With Thanksgiving and Christmas right around the corner, I have a feeling I'll be using this one a lot.

cutting a stick of butter / heirloomed

I am *such* a fan of pie for so many reasons. And while the filling may change, it's the base, the perfect crust, that truly makes the pie. I ran into a similar debate with the ingredients as I did when making biscuits. Some use butter, some use shortening, and others still use a mix, often butter and lard. I went back to my great grandmother "Nana's" handwritten recipe cards to find that she used Crisco (shortening) for her crust, and my mom confirmed that she too carries on this tradition.

mixing bowl of flour & butter / heirloomed
ice water for making pie crust / heirloomed
messy hands mixing pie crust / heirloomed
white lily flour for pie crust / heirloomed

I must say I'm not completely checking this one off my Bucket List just yet. I decided I'd branch out on my own for this one and give butter a try, since I've been eating shortening-based crusts my whole life. But I'd love to take the time to do a few versions side by side and see which I truly prefer.

But for the purposes of you knocking out an actual Pie Crust in time for Thanksgiving, I'm giving you the choice of two versions - my All Butter Pie Crust and my Nana's Shortening Pie Crust.

forming pie crust dough / heirloomed
dirty hands with pie crust dough / heirloomed

All Butter Pie Crust

This butter-based pie crust is flaky and delicious.


  • 11/4 cups all-purpose White Lily flour
  • 1/4 tsp kosher salt
  • 1/2 cup cold butter
  • 1/4 cup ice water


How to cook All Butter Pie Crust

  1. In a mixing bowl, combine your flour and salt. Cut in your cold, cubed butter until coarse crumbs form. Stir in water, a tablespoon at a time, until you are able to form the dough into a ball. Wrap and refrigerate for 4 hours or overnight to chill.
  2. Lightly flour your surface and roll out your dough to fit your pie plate, laying it over your plate. Press the dough into the bottom and along the sides of the pie plate as evenly as possible.
Created using The Recipes Generator
nana's pie crust handwritten recipe card / heirloomed

Nana's Pie Crust (Shortening)

This shortening-based version is what I grew up eating.


  • 1 1/2 cups flour
  • 3/4 cup Crisco
  • Dash of salt
  • 5 TBSP water


How to cook Nana's Pie Crust (Shortening)

  1. Mix flour / salt / shortening with fork - stir in water and turn into waxed paper shape in ball and set in refrigerator for 15 minutes. Turn onto floured base and roll. Makes 2 9" shells or 1 top & bottom shell.
Created using The Recipes Generator
vintage rolling pin rolling pie crust dough / heirloomed
making pie crust / heirloomed
heirloomed tip pie crust

Love to know your preferred method for Pie Crust at #HEIRLOOMED. I'll be trying this one again at Thanksgiving to see how it turns out. And, don't forget to give my Mom's Pie Crust Cinnamon Rolls a try with your leftover scraps - or save yourself the trouble and just make a double batch because these are my *favorite* of all time!


pie crust pin it



heirloomed is a lifestyle brand with a mission of "keeping heirlooms around for another generation." Our blog features stories about family recipes, creating traditions with your family, interior design and entertaining by mixing new and vintage pieces, classic style, and small town + historic travel. Our shop features a collection of "goods inspired by the past, for generations to enjoy" with an array of products and meaningful gifts including linen apronstabletop linensartceramics and beyond. Learn more at